Christianity and Culture: The Danger of Overspiritualizing Anxiety
Angela Shevchenko
Anxiety is an insidious liar. It has a unique way of making every thought that passes through your mind, even the most bizarre and unlikely, feel urgent and terrifyingly real. As if anxiety alone isn’t enough to nearly cripple your life, there’s an even greater danger. When you’re a Christian, the struggle can be more in-depth because anxiety can affect your spiritual life. It’s important to pay attention to this intersection between Christianity and culture.
Your Vivid Imagination
That imagination God gave you, the one that lets you paint, write, and come up with creative solutions, can also work against you if you have anxiety.
It’s great to exercise your brain to imagine a complicated storyline or to create a masterful piece of art. But if you have anxiety, that creative mind can also be the thing that starts you spiraling in an unhealthy direction.
Instead of thinking of lyrics to a song, anxiety forces your brain into catastrophizing benign or neutral events. Instead of dwelling on a spine-tingling ending for your first novel, your anxious brain begins to focus on potential future scenarios that don’t look so bright.
When you’re a Christ-follower, and you believe that God can and does speak to His people in quiet and beautiful ways, it can be difficult to decipher where your imagination stops and God’s warnings begin. Christianity and culture can clash, leaving you confused.
Warnings from God About Anxiety in Christianity and Culture
When an anxious thought shoots into your mind, your first instinct is to try to put it into context. Is this just a far-fetched thought? Is this worst-case scenario the most likely outcome? Is this a warning from God?
When anxiety speaks, it demands attention. It delivers messages that are both convincing and urgent. For a Christian who genuinely wants to be sensitive to God’s leading, it can feel almost irresponsible not to take every alarming thought seriously.
One of the most unfortunate attributes of anxiety is that it doesn’t care about the truth. It doesn’t filter out what is real or likely from the catastrophic, unlikely outcomes. Because anxiety hijacks your imagination, your anxious thoughts can present as very real.
When these thoughts strike, and you try to contextualize them, perhaps you consider whether or not they are from God in the process. If you start treating every anxious thought as a potential divine warning, you can get very confused. This confusion doesn’t just affect your emotions, but it can have serious consequences for your spiritual life as well.
Does God Warn His People?
God can absolutely warn His people. That’s not in question. He warned Joseph in a dream to flee Egypt with Mary and Jesus to escape Herod and later told him when it was safe to return. So, knowing that God has a track record of warning people is a given. But if you’re anxious, you might get confused as to exactly what your brain is producing and what God is saying. This discrepancy can be very disorienting.
There’s a significant difference between the Holy Spirit’s quiet conviction and anxiety’s relentless, spinning catastrophizing. God leads you to clarity and action that is supported by God’s good nature and Scripture. Anxiety leads you deeper and deeper into a confusing spiral with no clear way out. But in the fog of anxiety, it can be difficult to decipher the origins of the message.
Spiritual Misattribution
When you spiritualize your anxiety, a few things start to happen almost immediately. Here are some examples of things you may experience when you misattribute spiritual things to anxiety.
Discernment or Fear?
A dangerous consequence of overspiritualizing anxiety is that the fear that your anxiety produces can disguise itself as wisdom. If you are a chronic overthinker and an eager Christ follower, there’s a risk that the in the process of anticipating disaster, your brain may confuse this need for action as God’s warning, not a byproduct of anxiety that it truly is.
Lack of Faith
You may begin to interpret your anxiety itself as evidence of a spiritual failure. Instead of seeing anxiety as the human struggle, born of biology and learned behavior, that it is, you might dub it as evidence of a failed relationship with God.
If you believe your lack of faith is directly evidenced by your anxiety, then you might feel a sense of shame every time you have an anxious thought. Not only are you wrestling with the anxiety itself, but now you’re battling the condemnation and shame from it too.
Distorted View of God
When your anxiety begins to overtake your spiritual life, it can distort your view of God Himself. Instead of viewing Him as a loving and compassionate Father, you might start seeing Him as a distant being who is constantly disappointed and just waiting for you to fail.
In these moments, you start viewing God as an unpredictable communicator. You might think He drops terrifying, ambiguous hints of future catastrophes, leaving it up to your already exhausted mind to not only decode but react to or prevent. This in turn creates a hypervigilant faith. You feel like you’re walking on eggshells just trying to appease a god who values panic rather than resting in the arms of your faithful, loving Father.
Balance Christianity and Culture by Breaking Free
If you find yourself trapped in a cycle of spiritual misattribution, the good news is that you can break free. Once you separate your anxiety from your spiritual discernment, you can begin to see the difference between a misfiring nervous system and the voice of God.
Here’s how to start:
Test the Thought
Anxiety and the Holy Spirit often produce very different patterns, and learning to distinguish between them can help stop spiraling thoughts.
Anxiety is often urgent and chaotic, convincing you that danger is imminent, but unnervingly vague about what exactly you’re supposed to do about it. It often demands immediate attention but offers no concrete or logical path. It likes to keep the question of “What If?” at the forefront of the conversation and thrives in confusion and loves isolation.
The voice of the Holy Spirit, however, leads toward clarity, purposeful action, and restoration. Even when the Spirit convicts sharply, it comes with a sense of truth and a clear path forward. It is accompanied by peace and is supported by Scripture. (This offers another reason to hide those Scriptures in your heart!)
When an unidentified thought crosses your mind, test it against the nature of God. Pray and ask for discernment and confirmation. God is not trying to confuse or trap you, and He is faithful to guide His people with love and wisdom.
Consider the Biology
God created the human body with an intricate and complex nervous system.
When your body enters fight-or-flight mode, your brain is doing what it was designed to do under perceived threat. It pumps cortisol and adrenaline to prepare for the battle. If you have anxiety, this internal warning system is incredibly sensitive and can misfire.
Simply knowing that there is a biological explanation for your anxious symptoms can push you towards getting professional mental health help.
Therapy
Therapy can be incredibly helpful for Christians who are struggling with anxiety. It provides a designated place where you can sort through fearful thoughts before you assign spiritual meaning to them. A good therapist can also help you recognize patterns of catastrophizing and challenge those persistent irrational fears.
While your anxiety might be affecting your spiritual life, the roots are likely planted in biological tendencies and past trauma that your nervous system has learned to respond to. When you follow the trail of your anxiety back to these roots, you and your therapist can begin to identify the causes, and it’s easier to understand the beliefs and triggers that are also tied to your anxiety.
If you’re a believer who also suffers from anxiety, call our office today. Together with your therapist, you can deal directly with your anxiety and begin to understand the spiritual implications that go with it. Soon you will be able to separate your spiritual life from your physical reality. Through the power of God and therapy, you can break free of the spiritual confusion that you’ve been struggling with.
“Holding a Bible,” courtesy of Kelly Sikkema, Unsplash.com, CCO License


